what to do when a rescue won't take their animals back
You said yes because you wanted to help. You opened your home, bought supplies, learned care routines, and showed up - often for animals who came to you frightened, malnourished, or medically fragile. You did everything right.
But now the rescue won't respond when your contract is up or you need to return your fosters for any changes in circumstances.
Do not use this article as a guide to which rescues to avoid - this is not what it’s written for. It’s meant to help you advocate for the animals in your care best.
This Is More Common Than You Think
In September 2026, Upland police raided a Southern California nonprofit called Furget Me Not Purebred and rescued hundreds of cats from cramped, unsanitary conditions - animals that had been warehoused in a business park under the name of a rescue organization. Former employees documented the conditions for years; neighbors had filed lawsuits. Yet, the animals kept coming, and the fosters who tried to return them were met with silence, manipulation, or threats.
This is not an isolated incident. Across Southern California, rescue organizations operate with little oversight, no licensing requirements, and no accountability to anyone but themselves. They collect animals, they collect fosters, and when a foster reaches their limit - because life happens, because they are moving, because they are ill, because they simply cannot continue - some of these organizations disappear.
BCB has seen this firsthand. We know what it looks like when a rescue weaponizes the foster agreement against the very people who volunteered to help them.
Red Flags in Foster Agreements
Before you sign a foster agreement with any rescue, look for these warning signs:
Liquidated Damages Clauses
Any clause that states you will owe a specific dollar amount per day per animal if you return them is a red flag. Legitimate rescues do not need financial leverage over their volunteers.
Making Medical Emergencies the Foster's Financial Responsibility
A rescue that places a medically fragile animal with a foster and then disappears when the vet bills arrive is not a rescue - it is a liability transfer operation. Legitimate rescues cover emergency veterinary costs for animals in their care. Some agreements include language stating that fosters must cover initial costs and seek reimbursement, which is only reasonable if the rescue is actually reachable and actually reimburses.
Watch for agreements that cap what the rescue will cover, require pre-approval for emergency care that cannot wait for approval, or list emergency vets so far from the foster that transport itself becomes a crisis. These are not welfare policies. They are financial shields.
If an animal in your foster care has a medical emergency, your first obligation is to the animal in your care. Document the emergency, document your attempts to reach the rescue, and get the animal care. What happens financially after that is a separate conversation - and one where the rescue's silence will speak for itself.
Restrictions on Veterinary Care
Some agreements require fosters to use only the rescue's designated vets - even in emergencies. This is a control mechanism, not a welfare standard.
Grooming + Care Mandates Tied to the Rescue's Own Vendors
If an agreement requires you to attend the rescue's grooming workshops, use the rescue's groomer, and explicitly rejects the assessment of any outside veterinarian or groomer - that is not a welfare policy. That is a business model.
Clauses Stating the Rescue Must Approve Any Temporary Boarding
Life happens. If you need to travel or have an emergency, you should be able to make responsible care arrangements without first getting approval from an organization that may not respond to you for days.
Broad Property Claims Without Corresponding Accountability
"The animals are the property of the rescue and all decisions rest solely with the rescue" is reasonable language if the rescue is responsive, accountable, and actually making decisions in the animals' best interest. It is not reasonable when combined with an unresponsive organization that uses property claims as leverage without providing support.
For a deeper look at how to evaluate any rescue or shelter before working with them, read not all rescues or shelters are created equal →
Language that Blurs Fostering + Adoption
If the agreement includes permanent financial liability, ownership-adjacent language, or clauses that make it functionally impossible to return the animals - read it carefully. Consider having an attorney review it before you sign.
Your Rights as a Foster Parent
You are a Volunteer, Not an Employee
Foster agreements are contracts, but they are not employment contracts. California courts look skeptically at punitive clauses in volunteer agreements - particularly liquidated damages provisions that attempt to charge a foster parent a daily fee for animals they can no longer care for. These clauses are frequently unenforceable, especially when the foster made good-faith efforts to return the animals and was ignored.
Attempting to Return the Animals is not Abandonment
If you have documented attempts to contact the rescue, including texts, emails, voicemails, and the rescue has not responded, you have not abandoned the nimals. You have attempted to fulfill your obligation and been failed by the organization that placed them with you. Document everything. The timestamps matter.
The Rescue's Silence does not Create your Liability
Some foster agreements include clauses stating that the foster is responsible for all costs until the rescue retrieves the animals. These clauses assume the rescue will be reachable. When the rescue goes dark, the legal picture changes significantly. A court will not hold a volunteer indefinitely responsible for animals they tried to return.
You can Contact Animal Services directly (With Caveats)
If a rescue is unresponsive and you have animals in your care that you cannot continue to foster, you can contact your local animal services agency to understand your options. Use our shelter finder → to find the right agency for your city.
Be aware that most foster agreements prohibit surrendering animals directly to a shelter without the rescue's consent - and surrendering without authorization could be used against you as a breach of contract. Contact Animal Services for guidance, not necessarily to surrender. They have seen this situation before and may be able to help you navigate it or connect you with resources.
If the rescue is a New Hope partner, animal services may also be able to facilitate a conversation with the rescue on your behalf.
The Difference Between a Foster Agreement and an Adoption Contract
Some rescues blur this line deliberately. A foster agreement places animals in your temporary care: you are a caretaker, not the parent. An adoption contract transfers ownership/parenthood. If you signed a foster agreement but it reads like an adoption contract - if it includes ownership language, permanent financial liability, or clauses that prevent you from returning the animals under any circumstances, that agreement may not be enforceable as written. If you are unsure what you signed, read it carefully and consider consulting an attorney before making any moves.
What to Do With the Animals in the Meantime
While you are waiting for the rescue to respond, your legal and ethical obligation is to continue providing basic care for the animals in your home. You cannot simply leave them or surrender them to a stranger without consequences.
Board Them
Placing animals at a licensed boarding facility while you resolve the situation with the rescue is a reasonable, documented, responsible decision. A boarding facility creates a paper trail - the animals are accounted for, cared for, and retrievable. Keep all receipts and communication with the boarding facility.
We recognize that recommending boarding as an option benefits facilities like ours. You do not have to choose us, but it is still the right answer. The alternative, an animal left in an untenable situation while a rescue goes silent, is worse for everyone, especially the animal.
BCB does not discriminate based on where an animal comes from, or which rescue organization placed them. Our due diligence is to the client who signs our release of responsibility. We will never take sides in rescue disputes. Our priorities belong to the animals.
Document their Condition
This includes before and after photos, weight records, behavioral notes etc. If the animals arrive at a boarding facility malnourished or over-groomed or medically compromised, that documentation protects you from any claim that their condition deteriorated under your care.
Do not Transfer Them to an Individual without Authorization
Handing foster animals to a friend, family member, or another foster without the rescue's knowledge creates liability for everyone involved. If the rescue later claims the animals were improperly transferred, you are in a difficult position. Board them or keep them until the situation is resolved.
Seek Emergency Veterinary Care if Needed
An animal in your care who needs medical attention gets medical attention. Document your attempts to reach the rescue before seeking care. Keep all veterinary records and bills. If the rescue later refuses to reimburse costs they contractually agreed to cover, that refusal is documented.
What to Do If the Rescue Shows Up at Your Door
Some foster agreements include language giving the rescue the right to conduct home visits or retrieve animals at any time. Know your rights before that knock comes.
You Are Not Required to Let Anyone into your Home without a Warrant
A rescue organization is not law enforcement. They do not have the legal authority to enter your home without your consent, regardless of what their foster agreement says. A clause in a private contract does not override your Fourth Amendment rights.
You Can Ask for Identification
If someone arrives claiming to represent the rescue, ask for identification and do not open the door until you have confirmed who they are.
You Can Decline Entry and Offer an Alternative
If the rescue wants to retrieve the animals, you can offer to bring the animals outside, meet at a neutral location, or schedule a time that works for both parties - with a witness present.
Document the Interaction
If the rescue shows up unannounced and behaves in a threatening or aggressive manner, document it. Note the date, time, who was present, and what was said. If you feel unsafe, call the police.
Do Not Release the Animals under Duress
If someone is pressuring you to hand over the animals immediately and you feel unsafe, you are not obligated to comply - your safety and the animals’ safety matters. A chaotic, pressured handoff in a driveway with no documentation serves no one, including the animals.
If the Rescue Is a New Hope Partner (Los Angeles Specific)
The New Hope Program is a partnership between Los Angeles Animal Services and qualified rescue organizations. New Hope partners are given access to animals at city shelters - including animals on the euthanasia list - in exchange for meeting program standards and obligations.
Those obligations include maintaining humane foster conditions and responding to fosters who need to return animals.
If the rescue that placed animals with you is a New Hope partner and they have been unresponsive to your requests to return the animals, that may be a violation of their agreement with the city.
What You Can Do
Document all unanswered communications with timestamps
Contact LAAS directly and ask about the New Hope program and how to report a partner rescue
Ask whether the rescue is currently in good standing with the program
This will not always result in immediate action. But it creates a record, and it puts the rescue on notice that someone is paying attention.
If You Are Being Harassed
Threatening behavior, intimidation, and harassment are prohibited by the code of conduct of every legitimate animal rescue organization - including most of their own written policies. If a rescue is threatening to sue you, calling you repeatedly, contacting your family or employer, or using emotional manipulation to prevent you from returning animals, that is not enforcement of a foster agreement. That is harassment.
In California, harassment can be addressed through:
Civil Harassment Restraining Orders: available through California courts when someone engages in a course of conduct that causes substantial emotional distress and serves no legitimate purpose. A rescue organization threatening a volunteer with daily fines and legal action while refusing to respond to their messages may meet this threshold.
Reporting to the New Hope Program: if the rescue is a New Hope partner, harassment of fosters is a violation of the standards they agreed to uphold with the city. Document the harassment and report it to LAAS directly.
Reporting to the California Attorney General's Office: nonprofit organizations in California are regulated by the AG's Registry of Charitable Trusts. A rescue that harasses volunteers, misrepresents its operations, or misuses donor funds can be reported to the AG's office. This is the same oversight body that investigates hoarding cases like the one in Upland.
You do not have to accept harassment as the price of having tried to help. Document everything. Know your options.
Social Media Threats
Some rescues use their social media following as leverage - threatening to post about fosters publicly, encouraging followers to contact or harass a foster, or weaponizing their community against someone who tried to leave. This is a form of harassment regardless of the platform.
If a rescue threatens public posts about you or coordinates a social media campaign against you, document it. Screenshots with timestamps. If the conduct rises to the level of defamation, false statements of fact presented as true that damage your reputation, you may have legal recourse. Consult an attorney.
You are also not obligated to engage. Do not respond publicly. Do not argue in comments. Document and disengage.
When to Get a Lawyer
Not every difficult situation with a rescue requires legal counsel. But some do. Consider consulting an attorney when -
The rescue has sent you a formal demand letter or threatened to file suit
You have received communication from a lawyer representing the rescue
The rescue is making claims about money you owe that you believe are inaccurate or unenforceable
You are being harassed in a way that is affecting your safety or wellbeing
You are unsure what your foster agreement actually requires of you
The animals in your care have significant medical needs and the rescue is refusing to cover costs they agreed to
Many attorneys offer free initial consultations. California has several low-cost legal aid organizations that handle animal law and contract disputes. The Animal Legal Defense Fund also maintains resources for individuals involved in animal-related legal disputes.
You do not need to be wealthy to access legal help. You do need to ask.
Your Documentation Checklist
If you are in a difficult situation with a rescue, start documenting now. Here is what to save:
Every text message: screenshot with the date and time visible
Every email: do not delete; forward to a personal account as backup
Every voicemail: note the date, time, and caller
Photos of the animals: at intake, throughout the stay, and at transfer; include timestamps
Weight records: especially if the animals arrived malnourished
Veterinary records: all bills, diagnoses, and treatment notes
The foster agreement itself: your signed copy
Any receipts: food, supplies, boarding, veterinary costs
Social media posts: screenshot anything the rescue posts about you or the animals
Records of home visits or attempted visits: date, time, who appeared, what was said
Save everything in at least two places. A folder on your phone is not enough - email copies to yourself and use cloud storage. If this situation becomes legal, your documentation is your case.
What Responsible Fostering Should Look Like
A legitimate rescue:
Responds to fosters within a reasonable timeframe
Has a clear process for returning animals when a foster can no longer continue
Does not use financial penalties to trap volunteers
Accepts veterinary assessments from qualified professionals
Covers emergency veterinary costs when they said they would
Has a designated point of contact who is actually reachable
Does not harass, threaten, or intimidate fosters
Does not use their social media following as leverage against volunteers
If the rescue you are working with does not meet these standards, you are not obligated to continue indefinitely. You are a volunteer. You showed up. They need to as well.
BCB's Role
BCB is not a rescue. We do not pull animals from fosters and we do not have placement relationships with rescue organizations. Second Hop, our rescue fund, pulls red-listed animals from LA Animal Services and Long Beach Animal Care Services directly.
What We Do
we board animals, we provide care, and we take our responsibility to every animal in our facility seriously. We have seen what happens when fosters are trapped by organizations that prioritize their own interests over the animals in their care. We have seen it in the animals themselves - the over-grooming, the malnourishment, the behavioral signs of stress that accumulate when animals cycle through an unaccountable system.
We are sharing this information because we believe the foster community deserves to know their rights. Not because we have a stake in any particular organization - but because the animals do.
Resources